How I Select the Right Mutual Funds for My Clients: A CFP’s Perspective

When I sit with a client, whether it’s a young couple in Gurugram planning their first home, or a senior professional in Bengaluru preparing for retirement, one question always comes up:

“How do you actually choose which mutual fund is right for me?”

The truth is, I don’t rely on market noise, random recommendations, or flashy advertisements. My process is structured, data-backed, and deeply personal to each client’s goals. And to explain this, I like to use a simple analogy: booking the perfect airline journey.

Just like choosing a flight involves comparing routes, ticket prices, baggage rules, and even how smooth the flight will be, selecting a mutual fund involves looking at several ratios and performance indicators. Let me break it down.

⸻

1. Expense Ratio: The Ticket Price of Your Journey

When you book a flight, the ticket isn’t just for the seat—it includes airport taxes, fuel surcharges, and sometimes even hidden fees. Similarly, mutual funds charge an Expense Ratio—a small percentage of your money that goes towards managing the fund.

            •          A lower ticket price doesn’t always mean a better journey, but it leaves you with more money in your pocket.

            •          For long-term investing, even a 1% difference in expense ratio can save lakhs over the years.

As a CFP, I always balance cost vs. value. If a fund charges more but consistently delivers strong, risk-adjusted returns, I may still recommend it.

⸻

2. Sharpe Ratio: The Efficiency of the Flight

Imagine two airlines flying the same Delhi–Mumbai route. One uses fuel efficiently, giving you a smooth ride, while the other burns excess fuel and rattles through turbulence. Which would you prefer?

That’s exactly what the Sharpe Ratio tells us—it measures how efficiently a fund delivers returns compared to the risk it takes.

            •          A higher Sharpe Ratio = better returns for each unit of risk.

            •          I always prefer funds where the “fuel efficiency” is superior, because my clients deserve a smoother ride for their hard-earned money.

⸻

3. Alpha: The Pilot’s Skill

Every flight has a flight path. Some pilots stick to the minimum route, while others navigate smartly, avoiding turbulence and landing ahead of time.

This is what Alpha measures—how well the fund manager performs compared to the benchmark.

            •          A positive Alpha means the “pilot” (fund manager) has navigated smartly.

            •          A negative Alpha means the journey underperformed, despite having the same route as others.

When I see a consistent positive Alpha, I know the pilot knows what he’s doing—and I trust that for my clients.

⸻

4. Beta: Handling the Turbulence

On any flight, turbulence is inevitable. The difference lies in how the aircraft handles it.

Beta tells us how much a fund shakes compared to the market (the sky).

            •          Beta = 1: The fund moves exactly like the market.

            •          Beta > 1: It’s more turbulent—sharper ups and downs.

            •          Beta < 1: A smoother flight with fewer bumps.

For conservative clients, I look for a lower Beta (smoother ride). For aggressive investors, a higher Beta fund might work, as long as they’re comfortable with a bumpy journey.

⸻

5. Standard Deviation: The Range of Flight Delays

When booking a flight, you don’t just check the departure time—you check the airline’s record. Do they usually land on time or are they notorious for delays?

Similarly, Standard Deviation shows how much a fund’s returns deviate from the average.

            •          Low Standard Deviation = predictable landings (stable returns).

            •          High Standard Deviation = flights often delayed or early (volatile returns).

I match this to the client’s temperament. If someone panics with volatility, I avoid funds with a “delayed flight history.”

⸻

6. R-Squared: The Copycat Airline

Some airlines operate almost identical schedules, codesharing flights with bigger carriers. They’re essentially copycats.

That’s what R-Squared indicates—how closely a fund follows its benchmark.

            •          High R² (close to 100%) = The fund is basically an index fund.

            •          Lower R² = The fund is charting its own path.

I decide based on client goals: if they want low-cost and predictable, a high R² fund is fine. If they want a differentiated journey, I look for funds with a bit more independence.

⸻

How I Bring It All Together for My Clients

Selecting a fund isn’t about looking at one ratio in isolation. Just like choosing a flight, you don’t decide only based on ticket price or aircraft type—you look at the whole experience.

For my clients, I balance:

            •          Expense Ratio (ticket price) with Sharpe Ratio (efficiency)

            •          Alpha (pilot’s skill) with Beta & SD (handling turbulence)

            •          R² (copycat score) with the client’s goals and risk profile

Every investor is different. A young professional just starting their SIP can afford a bumpier ride (higher risk, higher return potential). A retiree depending on monthly withdrawals needs the smoothest flight possible.

That’s where my role as a CFP becomes critical—I’m not just booking any flight. I’m booking the right flight for your destination, your comfort, and your long-term safety.

⸻

Final Word: Why You Shouldn’t Fly Without a CFP

If you’re planning a once-in-a-lifetime international trip, would you just pick the cheapest flight on an app without checking the stops, airline reputation, or timings? Probably not.

So why do that with your financial journey?

Mutual funds are powerful wealth-building tools, but the wrong choice can delay or even derail your goals. As a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, my job is to act like your personal travel advisor for money—making sure your journey is efficient, safe, and aligned with where you want to land in life.

⸻

👉 Takeaway: Don’t pick mutual funds based on tips, past returns, or hearsay. Look deeper. And if you’d like a structured, personalized plan, let’s sit together and design your financial flight plan.

Perfect — let me expand this into the same Taresh Writes format by adding Situations A, B, and C to your article. I’ll keep it in first-person narrative and continue with the airline analogy framework while weaving in your professional CFP perspective.

⸻

How I Select the Right Mutual Funds for My Clients: A CFP’s Perspective

(Previous sections remain the same — Expense Ratio, Sharpe Ratio, Alpha, Beta, SD, R² explained using airline examples.)

⸻

Why Picking Funds Isn’t as Simple as It Looks

Now let me share three real-life situations I’ve observed. These aren’t about specific fund names but about investor behaviour. They show why choosing funds without a structured approach can sometimes feel like booking the wrong flight, missing the connection, or paying more for no extra benefit.

⸻

Situation A: The “Past Performance Passenger”

Imagine a traveller who books a flight only because it was on time last month. They don’t check whether the airline has a history of strikes, whether the aircraft is old, or whether the route is prone to weather delays.

That’s how many investors choose mutual funds—they open the fact sheet, see Fund A delivered 20% last year, and immediately jump in.

But here’s the problem:

            •          Past performance is just history. It doesn’t guarantee the same experience in the future.

            •          The pilot (fund manager) may have changed.

            •          The route (investment style) may now face turbulence.

            •          The airline (fund house) may have shifted its priorities.

For such investors, the “flight” often ends in disappointment. After chasing the highest returns, they are left with a bumpy ride when markets correct.

⸻

Situation B: The “Cheapest Ticket Hunter”

Another category is the investor who looks only at the lowest ticket price. In mutual funds, this means obsessing over the lowest expense ratio.

Yes, cost matters. But would you book the cheapest airline if it had the worst safety record or an inexperienced pilot? Probably not.

Take Fund B, for example:

            •          Its expense ratio is just 0.5% compared to another fund’s 1%.

            •          But its Alpha is consistently negative—it fails to beat its benchmark.

            •          Its Sharpe Ratio is weaker, meaning returns are not efficient for the risk taken.

By focusing only on cost, these investors miss the bigger picture: value creation. A fund with a slightly higher expense ratio but a skilled pilot (positive Alpha, good Sharpe Ratio) may take you much further in your financial journey.

⸻

Situation C: The “Guided Traveller” Who Trusts a CFP

Finally, let me share the experience of my clients who allow me to guide them—like a trusted travel planner.

When a client comes to me, I don’t look at just one shiny number. I begin with their destination:

            •          Is it a short trip (3–5 years) like buying a car?

            •          A medium trip (7–10 years) like children’s education?

            •          Or a long-haul international journey (15–25 years) like retirement?

Then I match the aircraft type (fund category) to the journey:

            •          Large Cap Funds → big, stable airlines (slower but reliable).

            •          Flexi Cap Funds → versatile aircraft that can adjust mid-flight.

            •          Balanced Advantage Funds → hybrid carriers that mix safety with speed.

From there, I compare 40 funds in that category and shortlist maybe 4 based on:

            •          Consistent Alpha (pilot’s skill).

            •          Sharpe Ratio (fuel efficiency).

            •          Beta and Standard Deviation (handling turbulence).

            •          R² (how closely they follow the benchmark).

Only after these checks, if the shortlisted funds are nearly identical, do I look at expense ratio to fine-tune the choice.

This is like choosing between four top airlines for a long journey: if they all have great safety, reliable pilots, and on-time records, only then I check which one offers the best ticket price.

For my clients, this structured approach means:

            •          No chasing the wrong flights (funds) based on flashy past performance.

            •          No compromising on safety just to save ₹200 on the ticket (expense ratio).

            •          Always being booked on the right aircraft, with the right pilot, for the right route, aligned with their financial goals.

⸻

My Closing Thought

Every investor has a choice. You can either:

            •          Jump on the first flight that looks good on paper (past performance).

            •          Hunt for the cheapest deal and hope it works out (lowest expense ratio).

            •          Or, you can let a professional travel planner—your CFP—design the journey with the right airline, pilot, and route for your unique goals.

As I tell my clients: “It’s not about the cheapest ticket or the flashiest airline. It’s about reaching your destination safely, comfortably, and on time.”

That’s how I choose mutual funds for my clients.

⸻

👉 Takeaway for You: If you’re selecting funds on your own, don’t stop at past returns or low fees. Think of your investment journey as a flight plan—and if you’d like a professional pilot in the cockpit, I’m here to guide you.

Part 3: The 9 Rules I Follow to Select the Right Mutual Fund for My Clients

Over the years, I’ve seen investors get overwhelmed with thousands of fund options, dozens of ratios, and conflicting advice. The truth is—most people don’t have the time, experience, or structured process to cut through the noise.

That’s where I step in. As a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™, I’ve developed 9 guiding rules that I follow every time I select a mutual fund for my clients. These rules are not random—they are a blend of global best practices, my decades of experience, and a deep understanding of Indian markets and investor behaviour.

Here are the 9 rules I live by:

⸻

Rule 1: Start with the Destination, Not the Vehicle

Before picking any fund, I first define where the client wants to go. Is it retirement, child’s education, wealth creation, or financial independence? Just like no pilot takes off without a destination, I don’t recommend a fund until I know the exact financial goal.

⸻

Rule 2: Match the Category to the Journey

Every category of mutual fund serves a different purpose:

            •          Large Cap = stability and long-term reliability.

            •          Flexi Cap = adaptability.

            •          Balanced Advantage = safety with growth.

I always match the fund category to the journey length and turbulence tolerance of my client.

⸻

Rule 3: Look Beyond Past Performance

Past returns are like yesterday’s flight timings. They show history but not the future. I don’t select funds just because they were “top performers” last year. Instead, I look for consistency—has the fund delivered across market cycles?

⸻

Rule 4: Expense Ratio Comes Last, Not First

Many investors make the mistake of chasing the lowest-cost fund. But I know from experience that value beats price. If a fund manager adds alpha and delivers efficient risk-adjusted returns, a slightly higher expense ratio is worth it.

⸻

Rule 5: Alpha is My Secret Filter

I pay close attention to Alpha—the fund manager’s ability to beat the benchmark. A skilled pilot matters more than a flashy airline ad. A consistently positive Alpha shows expertise, discipline, and decision-making ability, which is what I want for my clients.

⸻

Rule 6: Risk-Adjusted Returns Over Raw Numbers

A 14% return with wild swings isn’t always better than a 12% return with stability. I use measures like the Sharpe Ratio, Beta, and Standard Deviation to ensure my clients aren’t exposed to unnecessary turbulence.

⸻

Rule 7: Diversification is Non-Negotiable

No pilot flies with only one fuel tank. Similarly, I never recommend a single fund. I spread investments across categories—large cap, mid cap, hybrid—depending on the client’s overall plan. This ensures one bad patch doesn’t derail the journey.

⸻

Rule 8: Benchmark Awareness Matters

I always compare funds to their benchmarks. If a fund is just copying the index (high R²), I’d rather suggest a low-cost index fund. If it has room to add value (moderate R² with positive alpha), it earns my attention.

⸻

Rule 9: Personalisation Above All

The most important rule I follow is this: every client is unique.

            •          Two investors with the same salary may have different risk appetites.

            •          A newly married couple and a retired professional cannot be in the same “flight.”

That’s why my recommendations are never generic. They are tailored, structured, and aligned with personal goals, time horizon, and comfort with risk.

⸻

Why These Rules Matter

These 9 rules are not just technicalities—they are the backbone of how I protect and grow my clients’ wealth. While most investors get lost in chasing last year’s winners or saving a fraction of a percent in costs, I ensure that every recommendation I make is:

            •          Data-driven (based on ratios and research).

            •          Goal-focused (aligned with life priorities).

            •          Risk-aware (protecting clients from unnecessary shocks).

            •          Personalised (never “one size fits all”).

And because I follow this process every single time, my clients enjoy clarity, confidence, and peace of mind in their financial journey.

⸻

👉 Final Word from Me:

When you work with me, you’re not just getting access to mutual funds. You’re getting the value of my 37+ years of experience, my structured framework, and my commitment as a CFP to put your goals above everything else.

That’s the difference between investing randomly and investing with purpose.

⸻

Why My Clients Value This Approach

These 9 rules aren’t just theory—they’re the practical, lived framework that I apply for every client.

            •          They ensure data-driven decisions.

            •          They bring clarity in a noisy market.

            •          They align investments with life goals, not market gossip.

            •          They give clients peace of mind—knowing their journey is being planned with discipline.

That’s why many of my clients tell me, “Taresh, I finally feel like my money is on the right flight.”

⸻

Conclusion: Why You Shouldn’t Fly Without a CFP

Picking the right mutual fund isn’t about chasing last year’s winners or saving a few rupees on expenses. It’s about designing a flight plan that gets you safely to your destination.

As a CFP, I don’t just look at charts and ratios—I look at your life story, your goals, and your comfort with risk. Then I match the right funds to that journey.

So, if you’re tired of feeling lost in the maze of mutual funds, remember this: you don’t have to navigate alone.

With the right guide, your financial journey can be just like a perfectly planned flight—smooth, efficient, and always on course to land exactly where you want it to.

Disclaimer: The views expressed are for educational purposes only and do not constitute financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Please consult qualified professionals before making decisions. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks.

👉 Full Disclaimer | Disclosures | Terms of Use

👉Join my FAN page at:	facebook.com/CFPTareshBhatia
👉Follow on Facebook:	facebook.com/TareshBhatiaCFPro
👉Follow me on Instagram:	instagram.com/tareshbhatiacfp
👉Follow me on Threads:	threads.net/@tareshbhatiacfp
👉Follow me on Twitter:	twitter.com/tareshbhatiacfp
👉Follow me on LinkedIn:	linkedin.com/in/tareshbhatiacfp
👉Visit Website:	tareshbhatia.com
👉Read Blog:	blog.tareshbhatia.com
👉Buy my Book:	pages.razorpay.com/BookTRP
👉Join me on Telegram:	t.me/+v0ewUJQU0wowN2Jl
👉YouTube Channel:	youtube.com/@Taresh-Bhatia
👉Subscribe:	tinyurl.com/SubscTB
👉Join my Academy:	therichnessacademy.com
👉Complimentary Session-Limited Offer:	learn.therichnessacademy.com/web/checkout/686f9d1203ac6c6374689439
👉WhatsApp message directly:	wa.me/919810127906
👉Get Ebook:	tinyurl.com/TenEbook

📢 Join free live webinar —
Couple Finance Formula™ Register here